One of the most uncomfortable questions I’ve ever been asked at work had nothing to do with a project, a deadline, or a difficult customer.
It was, “So…how much do you make?”
The funny thing is that I don’t even remember how the conversation started. Someone mentioned raises, another person complained about inflation, and before I knew it, people were comparing salaries.
The room got quiet for a second while everyone waited for my answer.
I smiled, changed the subject, and moved on.
Over the last several years, conversations about salary have become much more common. Some people believe everyone should openly discuss their pay because it creates transparency and helps expose unfair compensation practices.
I understand that perspective.
But after spending years in leadership roles, interviewing employees, approving raises, and managing teams, I’ve come to a different conclusion.
Personally, I wouldn’t tell my coworkers my salary, and after years in leadership, I wouldn’t recommend it either.
That doesn’t mean discussing pay is illegal. In many workplaces, employees have the legal right to talk about their wages.
It also doesn’t mean every salary conversation ends badly.
What I am saying is this: I’ve seen what happens after those conversations take place, and more often than not, they create problems that didn’t exist before.
If you’re wondering whether you should tell your coworkers how much you make, here’s why I choose to keep my salary private.
Salary Is Only One Small Piece of the Story
One of the biggest mistakes people make is assuming two employees with the same job title should earn exactly the same salary.
In reality, compensation is much more complicated than that.
One employee may have negotiated a higher starting salary.
Another may have fifteen years of experience while someone else has five.
One person may consistently exceed expectations while another simply meets them.
Someone may have specialized certifications, unique technical skills, or responsibilities that aren’t obvious to everyone around them.
I’ve seen employees compare salaries without knowing any of those details.
They only knew one number.
That one number became the entire story in their mind.
The problem is that it rarely tells the whole story.
Comparison Has a Way of Stealing Your Happiness
Have you ever been perfectly happy with something until you found out someone else had more?
Maybe it was a bigger house.
A newer car.
A nicer vacation.
Salary works the same way.
You might genuinely enjoy your job and feel satisfied with your paycheck until you discover the coworker sitting next to you earns $8,000 more.
Suddenly, you’re asking yourself questions you never asked before.
“Why do they make more?”
“Am I being taken advantage of?”
“Do they work harder than I do?”
Sometimes those questions are valid. And sometimes they aren’t.
The problem is that once the comparison starts, it’s incredibly difficult to stop.
I’ve watched employees become frustrated over pay differences before they ever understood why those differences existed.
Instead of focusing on growing their careers, they became focused on someone else’s paycheck.
That’s not a healthy place to be. I’ve seen it absolutely consume a coworker of mine.
Salary isn’t like talking about your favorite restaurant or what you did over the weekend.
Once that number is out there, you no longer control where it goes.
Even people you trust can accidentally repeat it.
They may tell one friend, who tells another friend, who casually brings it up during lunch.
Before long, people you’ve never discussed money with know exactly what you earn.
I’ve seen this happen more than once.
Nobody intended to gossip.
Nobody set out to hurt anyone.
But salary information spreads surprisingly fast.
If you’re someone who values your privacy, it’s worth asking yourself whether you’re comfortable with your entire department knowing what you make.
Because that’s a real possibility.
Not Every Difference Means Someone Is Being Treated Unfairly
This is something I wish more people understood.
Companies don’t always pay employees differently because they value one person more than another.
Sometimes it’s simply business.
Maybe one employee was hired during a time when companies were competing aggressively for talent.
Maybe another person relocated across the country.
Or maybe someone accepted a lower salary in exchange for more vacation time or a flexible schedule.
Sometimes pay differences exist because one employee negotiated and another didn’t.
I’ve even seen situations where someone received a larger raise because they had another job offer.
Those situations aren’t always visible to coworkers.
Without that context, it’s easy to assume the company is playing favorites when the reality is much more complicated.
Work Friendships Can Change
This is probably the biggest reason I don’t recommend sharing salaries.
Money changes relationships.
Even when people don’t want it to.
Imagine you and your coworker have worked together for five years.
You get along well.
You help each other.
Then one afternoon your coworker finds out you make significantly more money.
Maybe you’ve been with the company longer.
Maybe you negotiated better.
Or maybe you’ve consistently received stronger performance reviews.
But none of that matters in the moment. All they hear is the number.
It’s human nature to compare ourselves with other people.
Unfortunately, those comparisons can quietly damage relationships.
I’ve seen coworkers stop collaborating as closely.
I’ve seen resentment build where none existed before.
The friendship didn’t end because of the salary itself.
It ended because of the assumptions that followed.
Managers Usually Can’t Explain Everything
This is something many employees never think about.
Managers often know exactly why two employees earn different salaries.
The problem is that they usually can’t tell you.
Imagine an employee asks why a coworker earns more money.
The manager may know it’s because that employee consistently performs at a higher level.
Or maybe they know the employee accepted a difficult assignment no one else wanted.
Maybe there were performance concerns that affected someone else’s raise.
Those conversations are confidential.
A good manager isn’t going to discuss another employee’s performance or compensation decisions.
That means employees are left filling in the blanks on their own.
Unfortunately, people don’t usually assume the best. They assume something unfair happened.
That’s one reason salary conversations often create frustration without giving people the full picture.
Let me take a moment and speak from my current experience. Right now I know three people in three different locations who do essentially the same job. Their salaries aren’t the same. One has been with the company for over ten years longer than the other two and has consistently negotiated for increases.
Looking only at the job title would make those differences seem unfair. Knowing the whole story changes the picture.
Let’s say you decide to tell a coworker exactly what you make.
What are you hoping happens next?
Maybe they’ll say you’re underpaid. Maybe they’ll tell you that you deserve more.
Or maybe you’ll discover you’re making exactly what everyone else makes.
But there are plenty of other possibilities.
What if they make less?
Now they feel frustrated every time they look at you.
What if they make more?
Now you’re questioning every decision your manager has made over the last few years.
What if someone else overhears the conversation?
Now people you’ve never intended to tell know your salary too.
I’ve watched enough workplace relationships over the years to know that salary conversations rarely end with everyone feeling better.
Usually, someone walks away disappointed. I’m saying “usually”, but in my case, it has never ended positively.
My Opinion
After years in leadership, I’ve found that comparing salaries usually creates more frustration than solutions. I’d rather spend my time becoming more valuable than wondering what someone else makes.
Your Value Is Bigger Than Your Paycheck
One thing I always tried to remind employees was that salary is only one part of a job.
Maybe your coworker makes a little more money.
Do they also work longer hours?
Do they travel every week?
Are they responsible for managing people?
Do they answer calls on nights and weekends?
Have they been with the company twice as long?
Those things matter.
I’ve known people who gladly accepted a lower salary because they valued flexibility, working from home, or having less stress.
I’ve also known people who chased the highest salary they could find and regretted it within a few months.
Money matters. Of course it does.
But it isn’t the only thing that matters.
What If Someone Asks You?
This is probably the question I get asked the most.
“What should I say if a coworker asks how much I make?”
You don’t have to be rude. You also don’t have to answer.
A simple response like these usually works well.
“I actually keep my salary private.”
“I’d rather not talk about money at work.”
“I’m happy with what I’m making, but I usually don’t discuss numbers.”
Most reasonable people will respect your answer and move on.
If they keep pushing, that’s more about them than it is about you.
You shouldn’t feel pressured to share personal financial information simply because someone asks.
If You Think You’re Underpaid, Do This Instead
Now let’s talk about the real issue.
Most people don’t ask about salaries because they’re nosy.
They ask because they’re worried.
Maybe they haven’t received a good raise in years.
Those are legitimate concerns. Check out 10 Signs You’re Underpaid if you feel like this may be your situation.
But instead of comparing yourself to one coworker, I’d encourage you to take a broader approach.
Research salary ranges for your position.
Keep track of your accomplishments throughout the year.
Document projects you’ve completed, money you’ve saved the company, and goals you’ve exceeded.
If you consistently perform above expectations, schedule a conversation with your manager.
Ask what you need to do to earn the next raise or promotion.
Those conversations are far more productive than comparing paychecks in the break room.
There Are Better Questions to Ask
Instead of asking a coworker, “How much do you make?”
Try asking questions that actually help you grow.
- “What skills helped you get promoted?”
- “What certifications have helped your career?”
- “How did you negotiate your salary?”
- “What projects helped you stand out?”
Those conversations teach you something valuable.
A salary number by itself doesn’t.
Are There Times When Salary Discussions Make Sense?
I do think there are situations where discussing compensation can be helpful.
For example, if you’re interviewing for a new position, talking with recruiters about salary expectations is completely normal.
Professional mentors can also provide guidance about what your skills are worth in the current market.
You can use salary surveys, reputable websites, and industry reports to understand typical compensation.
Those resources give you a much bigger picture than one coworker’s paycheck ever could.
That’s information I’d trust much more when deciding whether I’m being paid fairly.
My Final Thoughts
This is one of those topics where reasonable people can disagree.
Some people strongly believe employees should openly discuss salaries, and I respect that opinion.
For me, though, years of working in leadership have shaped a different perspective.
I’ve never personally seen a salary conversation make a workplace healthier. I have, however, seen them create resentment, frustration, and damaged relationships.
I’ve watched friendships at work become strained.
Also, I’ve seen employees become distracted by someone else’s paycheck instead of focusing on their own career growth.
Could sharing your salary work out just fine?
Absolutely.
But if you asked me whether I would recommend it, my answer would still be no.
I believe your time is better spent becoming more valuable than becoming more curious.
- Invest in your skills.
- Keep a record of your accomplishments.
- Ask for feedback.
- Give feedback after increases.
- Show your appreciation when you feel appreciation.
- Negotiate confidently.
- Know your worth.
Those things will have a much bigger impact on your income than knowing what the person in the next office makes.
At the end of the day, your career is your own. I would rather spend my energy building it than comparing it to someone else’s.
0 Comments